Skip to main content

Table 3 Scoring system used to assess hierarchy of evidence

From: How effective are on-farm mitigation measures for delivering an improved water environment? A systematic map

Category

Score

Hierarchy of evidence

Randomized

1

Yes—randomized (includes partial)

0

Not randomized

Control

3

Controlled BACI

2

Control

1

Comparator

0

None

Study length

1

Study length greater than or equal to a year

0

Study length less than a year

Replicates

2

Replicate temporal (includes time series) and spatial

1

Replicate temporal or spatial

0

No replicates

Study type

3

Manipulative study

2

Correlative study

1

Monitoring study

0

Sampling study

  1. Adapted from: Pullin and Knight [30].