Table 9 Metadata attributes planned for extraction during data coding
Category | Attribute name | Description |
|---|---|---|
Bibliographic | Publication type | Type of publication [peer-reviewed, book chapter, etc.] |
Author(s) | Article author(s) | |
Publication year | Year article was published [YYYY] | |
Title | Title of article | |
Journal name | Name of journal where article was published | |
Volume | Volume of journal in which article was published | |
Page numbers | Page numbers of article | |
DOI | DOI of article | |
URL | URL of article | |
Population | Population eligibility | Inclusion versus exclusion decision during full text screening stage for population [include, exclude] |
Reef type | Type of coral reef [atoll, fringing, barrier, etc.] | |
Reef relief | Vertical relief of reef [high, low] | |
Reef location | Location on reef where study occurred [fore reef, back reef, reef crest] | |
Reef energy regime | Categorical classification of reef energetic environment [high energy, low energy] | |
Description of coral reef | Description from article of coral reef | |
Intervention | Intervention eligibility | Inclusion versus exclusion decision during full text screening stage for intervention [include, exclude] |
Category of built structure intervention | Category of built structure intervention [artificial—engineered, artificial—repurposed, hybrid, natural, etc.] [Table 6] | |
Description of built structure intervention | Description from article of built structure intervention including quantitative or qualitative information like structure type and materials, structure size, structure date, deployment setting, etc | |
Material of built structure | Material of built structure [metal, concrete, rock, wood, plastic, 3D printed, etc.] | |
Proprietary name of built structure | If applicable, the proprietary name of built structure [Reef Balls, MARRS Spider, etc.] | |
Policy-relevant term for intervention | Policy-relevant term used to describe built structure intervention [nature-based solution, artificial reef, remediation structure] | |
Depth of built structure | Depth [mean or range, if available] of built structure location | |
Dates of built structure intervention | When the built structure intervention takes place | |
Cost of built structure intervention reported | Whether cost information on built structure intervention is reported [yes, no] | |
Coral restoration or related context of intervention | Whether the built structure intervention relates to coral restoration or related applications [coral restoration context; environmental mitigation context; coastal defense context] | |
Description of how intervention relates to coral restoration or related contexts | Description from article of how built structure relates to coral restoration or similar contexts | |
Study type | Study type eligibility | Inclusion versus exclusion decision during full text screening stage for study type [include, exclude] |
Study type | Type of study [experimental, modeling, etc.] | |
Study objective | Description from article of study objective | |
Study design | Description from article of study design | |
Study location | Description from article of study location | |
Geographic scale | Description from article of built structure intervention geographic scale [global, regional, national, subnational, local] | |
Country | Country where built structure intervention occurred | |
State | If built structure installed in United States, state where built structure intervention occurred | |
Water body | Name of water body where study was conducted | |
Category of comparator | Category of comparator used in study [before vs. after, presence vs. absence, different types of built structure interventions, etc.] | |
Description of comparator | Description from article of study comparator, if applicable | |
Outcome | Outcome eligibility | Inclusion versus exclusion decision during full text screening stage for outcome [include, exclude] |
Category of outcome | Whether performance outcome is ecological or physical [ecological or physical] | |
Subcategory of outcome | Subcategory of outcome [ecological: coral cover, coral condition, etc.]; see outcome typology [Tables 7, 8] | |
Description of outcome | Description from article of outcome | |
When outcome evaluation took place | Whether built structure outcomes were evaluated before, during, or after construction [before construction, during construction, after construction (≤ 1 yr), after construction (> 1 to ≤ 5 yrs), after construction (> 5 to ≤ 10 yrs), after construction (> 10 yrs), no evaluations conducted] | |
Frequency of outcome evaluation | Frequency of outcome performance evaluation, including units (e.g., every 3Â weeks for 5Â years) | |
Methods for outcome evaluation | Monitoring method(s) used to evaluate built structure performance outcome [net sampling, economic survey, etc.] | |
Metrics for outcome evaluation | Monitoring metric(s) used to evaluate built structure performance outcome [coral growth, coral mortality, etc.] | |
Data type for outcome evaluation | Whether data are qualitative, quantitative, or a combination of both to monitor performance outcome | |
Directionality of outcome | Directionality of measured performance outcome [positive, negative, mixed, neutral / no effect] | |
Additional | Notes | Notes on data extraction |