1. Study design | Case study: in-depth non-experimental qualitative study of a single location/protected area/local community within, usually studied over time in a real life context, using documents, interviews, observations. Frequently reports on unusual, extreme or rare cases Case series or Time series: quantitative non-experimental study in multiple time periods, outcomes measured during the intervention. If measurements exist before and after intervention—Before-After (BA) design Cross-sectional study (Control-impact (CI)): quantitative non-experimental study conducted in one point of time (e.g. survey), provides a snapshot. Not clearly established if intervention preceded the measured outcomes. Has non-randomly selected control groups Controlled before-and-after study (Before-After-Control-Impact (BACI)): quasi-experiment with controls, measure of outcomes before and after the intervention Controlled after only study: quasi-experiment with controls, measure of outcomes after the intervention ONLY Sequential mixed method: qual > quant OR quan > qual Concurrent mixed method design: qual and quant at the same time |
2. Comparator appropriateness | Is comparator appropriate for governance assessment? Is it relevant for the stated aims and conclusions of the study? Other methodological details? Describe |
3. Methodological detail | LOWÂ =Â no sufficient details on data collection and/or data analysis procedures, method selection not justified, MEDIUMÂ =Â no important methodological details missing, selection of methods justified and fits the research question; HIGHÂ =Â very detailed explanation of the data collection and analysis procedures, info on ethical approval included, study limitation, confounding and biases commented upon |
4. Measurements of ecological outcomes | Subjective/perception based or self-reported (=0); Objective (=1). E.g.: changes in the forest cover assessed through analysis of satellite images versus perception of the changes in forest cover reported by the local people) |