What are the environmental impacts of property rights regimes in forests, fisheries and rangelands?

Table 10 Reported effects of contextual factors across property regimes in fisheries

Citation number and article title	Reported outcome (for state)	Contextual factors
		Monitoring		Resource use pressure		Protected area		Positive regime characteristics
		Yes	No	Low	High	Yes	No	Present/absent
Comparisons between state and open access
Götz et al. [70]	Positive					x
Kamukurua et al. [71]	Positive	x				x
Walmsley and White [51]	Positive	x				x
Mayfield et al. [52]	Positive					x
Mayfield et al. [52]	Positive					x
Camargo et al. [49]	Neutral					x
Shank and Kaufman [50]	Neutral		x		x	x
Shank and Kaufman [50]	Neutral	x			x	x
Walmsley and White [51]	Neutral	x				x		Absent
Mayfield et al. [52]	Neutral					x
Mayfield et al. [52]	Neutral					x
Lopes et al. [53]	Neutral					x
Comparisons between community and open access
Walmsley and White [51]	Positive	x				x
Cinner et al. [72]	Positive					x
Clements et al. [73]	Positive			x		x
Clements et al. [73]	Positive			x		x
Clements et al. [73]	Positive			x		x
Aswani and Sabetian [56]	Positive					x
Aswani and Sabetian [56]	Positive					x		Absent
Aswani and Sabetian [56]	Positive					x
Halpern et al. [54]	Neutral	x		x		x
Halpern et al. [54]	Neutral	x		x		x
Halpern et al. [54]	Neutral	x		x		x
Yasue et al. [48]	Undetermined	x			x	x
Comparisons between mixed and open access
Francini-Filho and Mourab [55]	Positive	x		x		x		Present
Walmsley and White [51]	Positive	x				x
Shank and Kaufman [50]	Neutral		x		x	x
Silvano et al. [74]	Neutral			x		x
Yasue et al. [47]	Undetermined	x			x	x

ISSN: 2047-2382