From: What are the environmental impacts of property rights regimes in forests, fisheries and rangelands?
Citation number and article title | Reported outcome (for state) | Contextual factors | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Monitoring | Resource use pressure | Protected area | Positive regime characteristics | |||||
Yes | No | Low | High | Yes | No | Present/absent | ||
Comparisons between state and open access | ||||||||
 Götz et al. [70] | Positive |  |  |  |  | x |  |  |
 Kamukurua et al. [71] | Positive | x |  |  |  | x |  |  |
 Walmsley and White [51] | Positive | x |  |  |  | x |  |  |
 Mayfield et al. [52] | Positive |  |  |  |  | x |  |  |
 Mayfield et al. [52] | Positive |  |  |  |  | x |  |  |
 Camargo et al. [49] | Neutral |  |  |  |  | x |  |  |
 Shank and Kaufman [50] | Neutral |  | x |  | x | x |  |  |
 Shank and Kaufman [50] | Neutral | x |  |  | x | x |  |  |
 Walmsley and White [51] | Neutral | x |  |  |  | x |  | Absent |
 Mayfield et al. [52] | Neutral |  |  |  |  | x |  |  |
 Mayfield et al. [52] | Neutral |  |  |  |  | x |  |  |
 Lopes et al. [53] | Neutral |  |  |  |  | x |  |  |
Comparisons between community and open access | ||||||||
 Walmsley and White [51] | Positive | x |  |  |  | x |  |  |
 Cinner et al. [72] | Positive |  |  |  |  | x |  |  |
 Clements et al. [73] | Positive |  |  | x |  | x |  |  |
 Clements et al. [73] | Positive |  |  | x |  | x |  |  |
 Clements et al. [73] | Positive |  |  | x |  | x |  |  |
 Aswani and Sabetian [56] | Positive |  |  |  |  | x |  |  |
 Aswani and Sabetian [56] | Positive |  |  |  |  | x |  | Absent |
 Aswani and Sabetian [56] | Positive |  |  |  |  | x |  |  |
 Halpern et al. [54] | Neutral | x |  | x |  | x |  |  |
 Halpern et al. [54] | Neutral | x |  | x |  | x |  |  |
 Halpern et al. [54] | Neutral | x |  | x |  | x |  |  |
 Yasue et al. [48] | Undetermined | x |  |  | x | x |  |  |
Comparisons between mixed and open access | ||||||||
 Francini-Filho and Mourab [55] | Positive | x |  | x |  | x |  | Present |
 Walmsley and White [51] | Positive | x |  |  |  | x |  |  |
 Shank and Kaufman [50] | Neutral |  | x |  | x | x |  |  |
 Silvano et al. [74] | Neutral |  |  | x |  | x |  |  |
 Yasue et al. [47] | Undetermined | x |  |  | x | x |  |  |