What are the environmental impacts of property rights regimes in forests, fisheries and rangelands?

Ojanen, Maria; Zhou, Wen; Miller, Daniel C.; Nieto, Sue Helen; Mshale, Baruani; Petrokofsky, Gillian

doi:10.1186/s13750-017-0090-2

Environmental Evidence

Table 9 Reported effects of contextual factors across property regimes in forests

From: What are the environmental impacts of property rights regimes in forests, fisheries and rangelands?

Property regime	Citation number and article title	Reported outcome (compared to state)	Contextual factors
			Monitoring		Resource use pressure		Protected area		Positive regime characteristics
			Yes	No	Low	High	Yes	No	Present/absent
Comparisons with state regime
Community	Nautiyal and Kaechele [37]	Positive					x		Present
Community	Nautiyal and Kaechele [37]	Positive					x		Present
Community	Nautiyal and Kaechele [37]	Neutral					x
Community	Nautiyal and Kaechele [37]	Negative					x
Community	Hayes [39]	Positive	x					x	Present
Community	Lambrick et al. [40]	Positive	x		x			x	Present
Community	Måren et al. [41]	Positive				x		x
Community	Sudtongkong and Webb [42]	Positive	x		x			x	Present
Community	Sudtongkong and Webb [42]	Positive	x		x			x	Present
Private	Vuohelainen et al. [35]	Positive	x		x		x
Private	Vuohelainen et al. [35]	Positive	x		x		x
Private	Vuohelainen et al. [35]	Positive	x		x		x
Private	Vuohelainen et al. [35]	Positive		x	x		x
Private	Vuohelainen et al. [35]	Positive	x		x		x
Private	Vuohelainen et al. [35]	Negative				x	x
Community	Vuohelainen et al. [35]	Negative	x			x		x	Present
Community	Vuohelainen et al. [35]	Negative				x		x
Community	Vuohelainen et al. [35]	Negative				x		x
Open access	Hammi et al. [36]	Negative		x	x			x	Absent
Open access	Hammi et al. [36]	Negative		x	x			x	Absent
Community	Bossart et al. [38]	Negative	x				x
Community	Bossart et al. [38]	Negative	x				x
Community	Bossart et al. [38]	Negative	x				x
Community	Bossart et al. [38]	Negative	x				x
Comparisons with private regime
Community	Vuohelainen et al. [35]	Negative	x			x		x	Present
Community	Vuohelainen et al. [35]	Negative				x		x
Community	Vuohelainen et al. [35]	Negative				x		x
Community	Gibson et al. [44]	Undetermined	x					x	Present
Community	Gibson et al. [44]	Undetermined		x				x	Present
Community	Gibson et al. [44]	Undetermined		x				x	Present
Mixed	Rai and Uhl [45]	Undetermined		x		x		x	Absent
Community	Tucker [46]	Undetermined	x			x		x	Absent
Community	Tucker [46]	Undetermined				x		x	Absent
Community	Tucker [46]	Undetermined				x		x	Absent

x presence, empty cell study did not have the information

Back to article page

ISSN: 2047-2382

Contact us

Submission enquiries: Access here and click Contact Us
General enquiries: info@biomedcentral.com