Low susceptibility to bias | High susceptibility to bias | Bias type | |
---|---|---|---|
Study design | |||
Comparison domain | Comparison across both space and time (e.g., BACI) | Comparison across space or time only (e.g., CI, BA) | Selection bias |
Control matching at study initiation (not applicable to BA studies, where control and intervention take place at the same site) | Well-matched control and intervention sites, close in proximity or clearly similar, but without spillover effects | Well-matching not evident, other factors likely to influence difference between treatment and control sites | Selection bias |
Effect modifiers and confounding factors during study period | No or minimal presence of co-interventions, co-exposures or trends present that are likely to differ between groups, baseline environmental conditions similar to intervention period; or if present, confounding factors are accounted for | Co-interventions, co-exposures or trends present that are likely to differ between groups, e.g., differing climate conditions, weather events, or other environmental or anthropogenic changes; and factors are not accounted for | Performance bias |
Groundwater measurements | |||
Measurement similarity and representativeness | Similar and representative measurements across groups, unlikely to differ systematically | Systematic differences in measurements, outcomes not assessed similarly, or measurements unlikely to be representative | Detection bias |
Other | |||
Confounding variables not included in other bias types (e.g., funding source) | No obvious confounding factors, or confounding factors present but accounted for | Confounding factors stated or obviously present but not accounted for | Other bias |