Criteria | Inclusion | Exclusion |
---|---|---|
Types of study | Any primary study with a comparator, including observational and manipulative | Simulation studies, review papers, and policy discussions |
Studies which are in the English language. Note: majority of conservation papers from previous systematic map related to SEA regions are in English, hence the language of choice | Studies which are in languages other than English | |
Population | Populations in the villages/urban areas within the coastline (any community classified as coastal by the authors of each study) in the SEA region. SEA is composed of 11 countries: Brunei, Burma (Myanmar), Cambodia, Timor-Leste, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, Vietnam | Populations outside of the coastline in the Southeast Asia region |
Interventions | Studies that reported about marine sites that are either being managed formally by the ‘national and local government’ or ‘non-governmental organisations’ or ‘people’s organisations’ in the Southeast Asia region, for environmental conservation | Studies without any intervention related to marine sites |
Outcome measures | Poverty status in terms of economic or/and material living standards. We followed the definition according to the systematic map (Garside and Eales 2020 in press): | Studies that did not report poverty status in terms of the economic and material living status |
Economic living standards include measures of income, employment, employment opportunities, wealth/poverty, savings, payments, and loans | ||
Material living standards include measures of access to and availability of food, fibre, fuel and basic infrastructure (electricity, water, telecommunications, and transportation); provision of shelter; and assets owned (e.g., television) | ||
Comparison | Any comparator which falls under one of the followings: | No comparator |
(i) A different site with no marine protection | ||
(ii) The same site, before the marine protection was implemented | ||
(iii) A different site, with another marine protection implementation |