Skip to main content

Table 2 Comparison of modal assessment ratings (colours) for all evidence reviews and selected subgroups

From: Standards of conduct and reporting in evidence syntheses that could inform environmental policy and management decisions

  1. When two colours are given this is due to bimodal pattern in assessments. CEESAT criteria on top line are: 1. Review question, 2. Review planning, 3.1 Search strategy, 3.2 Search comprehensiveness, 4.1 Eligibility criteria, 4.2 Screening consistency, 4.3 screening reporting, 5.1 Critical appraisal method, 5.2 Critical appraisal consistency, 6.1 data extraction method, 6.2 Data extraction reporting, 6.3 Data extraction consistency, 7.1 Data synthesis method, 7.2 Data synthesis reporting, 7.3 Data synthesis exploration of variability, 8 Review limitations. SR stands for Systematic Review