Table 12 Metadata attributes to be extracted during data coding for articles that pass both title and abstract and full text screening stages.
Category | Attribute name | Description |
|---|---|---|
General | Article ID | Unique identifier for each article |
| Â | Full text eligibility | Whether article is eligible for inclusion based on full text screening (include, exclude) |
| Â | Screener name | Name of individual who screened full text |
| Â | Screening date | Screening date of full text |
| Â | Full text available | Whether full text is available for article (available, unavailable) |
| Â | Screening notes | Screener notes on full text screening stage |
Bibliographic | Publication type | Type of publication (peer-reviewed, book chapter, etc.) |
| Â | Author(s) | Article author(s) |
| Â | Publication year | Year article was published (YYYY) |
| Â | Title | Title of article |
| Â | Journal name | Name of journal where article was published |
| Â | Volume | Volume of journal in which article was published |
| Â | Page numbers | Page numbers of article |
| Â | DOI | DOI of article |
| Â | URL | URL of article |
Population | Population eligibility | Inclusion versus exclusion decision during full text screening stage for population (include, exclude) |
| Â | Type of coastal ecosystem | Type of coastal ecosystem where NBS is located (salt marsh, seagrass, mangrove, kelp, coral reef, shellfish reef) |
| Â | Description of coastal ecosystem | Description from article of ecosystem type |
Intervention | Intervention eligibility | Inclusion versus exclusion decision during full text screening stage for intervention (include, exclude) |
| Â | Category of NBS intervention | Category of NBS intervention (living shoreline, planting or seeding, artificial substrate addition); see intervention typology, Table 7 |
| Â | Coastal protection context of NBS intervention | Whether the NBS intervention seeks to achieve a stated coastal protection goal (stated goal; evaluated outcome) |
| Â | Policy-relevant term for intervention | Policy-relevant term used to describe NBS intervention (NBS, NBI, NNBF, etc.) |
| Â | Description of NBS intervention | Description from article of NBS intervention including quantitative or qualitative information |
| Â | Description of NBS' coastal protection goal | Description from article of coastal protection goal that NBS intervention seeks to achieve |
| Â | Coastal protection context | Whether coastal protection was identified as an intended goal or intent, evaluated outcome, or implied through framing (intended, assessed, implied) |
| Â | Dates of NBS intervention | When the NBS intervention takes place |
| Â | Cost of NBS intervention reported | Whether cost information on NBS intervention is reported (yes, no) |
Study type | Study type eligibility | Inclusion versus exclusion decision during full text screening stage for study type (include, exclude) |
| Â | Study type | Type of study (experimental, modeling, etc.) |
| Â | Study objective | Description from article of study objective |
| Â | Study design | Description from article of study design |
| Â | Study location | Description from article of study location |
| Â | Geographic scale | Description from article of NBS intervention geographic scale (global, regional, national, subnational, local) |
| Â | Country | Country where NBS intervention occurred |
| Â | State | If NBS intervention used in United States, state where NBS intervention occurred |
| Â | Water body | Name of water body where study was conducted |
| Â | Category of comparator | Category of comparator used in study (before vs. after, presence vs. absence, different types of NBS interventions, etc.) |
| Â | Description of comparator | Description from article of study comparator, if applicable |
Outcome | Outcome eligibility | Inclusion versus exclusion decision during full text screening stage for outcome (include, exclude) |
| Â | Category of outcome | Whether performance outcome is ecological, physical, economic, or social (ecological, physical, economic, social) |
| Â | Subcategory of outcome | Subcategory of outcome (social: safety and security, culture, etc.); see outcome typology, Tables 8, 9, 10, 11 |
| Â | Description of outcome | Description from article of performance outcome |
|  | When outcome evaluation took place | Whether NBS performance outcomes were evaluated before, during, or after construction [before construction, during construction, after construction (≤ 1 yr), after construction (> 1 to ≤ 5 yrs), after construction (> 5 to ≤ 10 yrs), after construction (> 10 yrs), no evaluations conducted] |
| Â | Frequency of outcome evaluation | Frequency of outcome performance evaluation, including units (e.g., every 3Â weeks for 5Â years) |
| Â | Methods for outcome evaluation | Monitoring method(s) used to evaluate NBS performance outcome (net sampling, economic survey, etc.) |
| Â | Metrics for outcome evaluation | Monitoring metric(s) used to evaluate NBS performance outcome (fish biomass, job creation, etc.) |
| Â | Data type for outcome evaluation | Whether data are qualitative, quantitative, or a combination of both to monitor performance outcome |
| Â | Directionality outcome | Directionality of performance outcome (positive, negative, mixed, neutral/no effect) |