Skip to main content

Table 8 Typology of ecological outcomes.

From: What evidence exists on the performance of nature-based solutions interventions for coastal protection in biogenic, shallow ecosystems? A systematic map protocol

Category

Definition

Examples

Population/species

Outcomes focused on characteristics of or changes in species or populations

Abundance; density; biomass; demography (age, size structure); behavior (time spent hiding; time spent feeding; distance from habitat); recruitment; reproduction (fecundity; spawning aggregations, reproductive individuals); species range and spatial extent; dispersal (migration patterns, natal homing, habitat use), connectivity (measured with genetics, microchemistry), body conditions (disease incidence, parasitism rate, toxin level), adaptability, resilience, resistance, or recovery at species level (genetic diversity, heat resistance, salinity tolerance, other stressor tolerance)

Community

Outcomes focused on characteristics of or changes in communities

Community composition and species diversity (abundance, richness, evenness); trophic or food web structure (abundance or diversity of organisms within trophic levels, food web redundancy, number of trophic levels); functional redundancy (degree to which species or groups of species generate similar functions); resilience, resistance, or recovery at community level

Habitat

Outcomes focused on characteristics of or changes in habitats

Habitat quantity (cover and extent—area, volume, height, width, cover; gain or loss in extent); habitat quality (3D complexity, rugosity, fractal dimensions, foundation species density); habitat connectivity or biogeography (degree to which habitats are connected, such as seagrass material in fish gut contents; spillover); upland habitat transition boundary or extent; habitat transgression, migration, or transition

Biological interactions

Outcomes focused on characteristics of or changes in biological or species interactions like facilitation, competition, predation

Competition; predation; mutualism; commensalism; facilitation; herbivory; omnivory; carnivory; zooplanktivory; water filtration (e.g., shellfish filtering water or vegetation slowing water movement); invasive or non-native species interactions with other organisms

Spatial functions and processes

Outcomes focused on characteristics of or changes in spatial ecosystem functions and processes

Spatial distribution, including zonation; connectivity (not at species or habitat level, but rather ecosystem level); dispersal; transgression or migration of ecosystem [space]

Temporal functions and processes

Outcomes focused on characteristics of or changes in temporal ecosystem functions and processes

Succession; colonization; transgression or migration of ecosystem [time]; reaction to pulse or chronic disturbances; resilience, resistance, and recovery

Ecosystem productivity

Outcomes focused on characteristics of or changes in ecosystem productivity

Primary productivity; secondary productivity; energy flow; photosynthesis; respiration; decomposition

Nutrient cycling

Outcomes focused on characteristics of or changes in nutrient cycling

Denitrification; nitrification; carbon sequestration; carbon cycling and storage; phosphorus cycling

Ecosystem health

Outcomes focused on characteristics of or changes in ecosystem health

Turbidity; harmful algal blooms; bacteria, viruses, and fungi; toxins and contaminants; microplastics; debris; bioaccumulation; nutrient levels and pollution; invasive or non-native species ecosystem effects; tipping points and thresholds; resilience, resistance, or recovery at ecosystem level